The winner of the Marvel Costume Contest at the recent New York Comic Con has a, well, wonderfully scandalous origin.

Remember the Steampunk Iron Man outfit that made an appearance at NYCC and wow its way into winning the Marvel Costume Contest? A brilliantly-made get-up that creatively re-imagines the Iron Man mythos during the Industrial Age.

As it turned out, the suit is actually repainted from a Tin Man suit originally created for an indie steampunk short film, Heartless: The Story of the Tin Man, which retells the origins of the Tin Woodsman from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. And you're right: Somebody has gotten extremely pissed off with this.

Namely, Bill Johnson, the lead designer of the original Tin Man costume, who has this to say, over at The Effects Lab Forum:

Just found out that the Tin Man suit was taken and modified into an "Iron Man" suit that won the costume contest at the NY Comic Con by my ex assistant. The suit was changed without my knowledge or permission and I'm royally angered by this action. It's also sad to see that the only screen used version of the suit that exists, is now a cheapened knock off of a popular character. I don't get people anymore and it makes me want even more to become more reclusive.

Matt Silva, the one behind the "upgraded" suit, was actually one of the assistants who worked on the costume, and was incidentally left to take care of the suit after the movie's promotional run ended. After the earlier outrage from John, Silva contacted Johnson, who has since simmered down with this to say:

I had a long talk with him and we ironed things out. It was all part of a huge lapse in good judgment that blew up. I hate to see a piece of history, such as this piece, fade away like that. I guess that I am getting old and sentimental.
He was acting as the person who was holding on to the suit for promotional events for the film. He did help build it and said that it was constantly needing repair (which I do believe). He's not very old and just showed a serious lapse of good judgment. As for the suit's ownership, that is a grey area. The company that made the film paid for the materials and did give me a very small amount of money for all the work that I did (Production design, make up effects, etc) just to help with my bills while I took time off to do the project. I have most of the items created or bought for the film, but agreed to let them hold on to the suit for display in their office or promotion for the film. I would not say that it was stolen, but was not used in the manner of our agreement. He truly feels horrible for doing such an idiotic thing and I know that he is really a good kid at heart. Ultimately, what's done is done and I'm sure he won't do such a stupid thing again in the future.

Interestingly, the director of Heartless, Brandon McCormick, wrote to Gizmodo with the below positive comments on the suit upgrade:

I want to set the record straight, as I feel this sheds a bad light on our film company, but more importantly on the artists that call Whitestone home.
We were not aware of Matt Silva's intentions to modify the suit, nor were we a part of planning it. While that is true, and we had a private conversation about the issue, I personally thought his modifications were incredible and as an entire film company we were proud and supportive of the success of one of our artists.
We thought that a retweet by Jon Faveru and Stan Lee warranted hearty pat on the back!
While we are proud of our little short film 'Heartless: The Story of the TinMan" we do not regard it as a piece of "film history", and feel that Matt was responsible for making sure both WS and Bill Johnson got credit for their work while promoting the suit.
Both artists worked very hard on Heartless, and we were proud of the work they did.
I wanted to be clear as the films creator and speaking for my production company that we have no problems with Matt. The problems posted all over the Internet are from the suit's lead designer, Bill Johnson and his accusations and frustrations do not represent Whitestone.

As bureaucratic as the above may sound, I had to agree with the director. While the efforts made in the upgrade might not be as much as creating one from scratch, Silva did made a good job in the modification and in the process, inject new life in an otherwise forgotten suit.

In closing, check out more of shots of the suit.

Source: Gizmodo

  1. vanteeq Said,

    Actually, the design the cosplayer used was based on the design used on an actual Marvel comic from several years back. Don't get angry at the cosplayer, he had a legitimate source

    Posted on May 10, 2011 at 11:24 AM

  2. Anonymous Said,

    Actually, it's the same freaking suit. Idiot. He didn't take the design. He took the actual suit.

    Posted on May 18, 2012 at 4:32 PM


Post a Comment

Presented in Zombie-Vision TV

Death Stranding E3 2018 Trailer

Posted by The Daily Zombies

Death Stranding E3 2018 Trailer

Posted by The Daily Zombies

Cyberpunk 2077: First Look - E3 2018

Posted by The Daily Zombies

Devil May Cry 5: First Look - E3 2018

Posted by The Daily Zombies

Halloween: First Look - Undead Monday

Posted by The Daily Zombies

The Girl in the Spider's Web: First Look

Posted by The Daily Zombies

Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse - New Trailer

Posted by The Daily Zombies

The Lego Movie 2: The Second Part - First Look

Posted by The Daily Zombies

Facebook of the Dead

Death Toll Or Rather Lack Thereof...

decaying walking corpses, compelled by their unshakably irresistible hunger for human flesh, had gotten their daily fix of brain tissue. Want some?

Undead United